Kenny Pickett injury update: How veteran's hamstring issue affects Shedeur Sanders, more in Browns' QB competition | Sporting News Canada


🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source
Pickett missing time opens the door for other Cleveland quarterbacks vying for the starting job.

Cleveland Browns' Quarterback Conundrum: Kenny Pickett's Injury Sparks Debate on Shedeur Sanders and Internal Competition
In the ever-turbulent world of NFL quarterback dynamics, the Cleveland Browns find themselves at a crossroads once again, grappling with injuries, performance issues, and long-term planning. Recent developments, including an injury to former Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett—now with the Philadelphia Eagles—have unexpectedly rippled into discussions about the Browns' own signal-caller situation. While Pickett's setback occurred in a separate context, it has fueled broader conversations about quarterback fragility and the Browns' potential interest in high-profile prospects like Colorado's Shedeur Sanders. This comes amid an intensifying internal competition for the Browns' starting role, highlighting the franchise's ongoing quest for stability under center.
To understand the current landscape, it's essential to rewind to the Browns' recent history. The team made a blockbuster trade for Deshaun Watson in 2022, committing massive resources to the former Houston Texans star in hopes of elevating their offense to elite status. However, Watson's tenure has been marred by off-field controversies, suspensions, and inconsistent play on the field. In 2023, he appeared in only six games due to injuries, forcing the Browns to rely on a carousel of backups including P.J. Walker, Dorian Thompson-Robinson, and Joe Flacco, who provided a late-season spark but couldn't sustain long-term momentum. Entering the 2024 season, the Browns bolstered their depth by signing veteran Jameis Winston and Tyler Huntley, while retaining Thompson-Robinson, creating what head coach Kevin Stefanski has described as a "healthy competition" for the backup spots behind Watson.
The catalyst for the latest buzz, however, stems from Kenny Pickett's injury during a preseason game. Pickett, who was traded from the Steelers to the Eagles in the offseason, suffered a rib injury that sidelined him temporarily, raising questions about his durability and readiness as Philadelphia's backup to Jalen Hurts. While this event is unrelated directly to Cleveland, it has drawn parallels in NFL circles to the Browns' own vulnerabilities. Analysts have pointed out that Pickett's struggles with injuries and inconsistency mirror some of the challenges Watson has faced, prompting speculation about how teams like the Browns might approach their quarterback rooms moving forward. In particular, this has amplified chatter about the 2025 NFL Draft, where Shedeur Sanders emerges as a tantalizing option for quarterback-needy franchises.
Shedeur Sanders, the son of NFL legend and current Colorado head coach Deion Sanders, has been turning heads with his poise, arm talent, and leadership on the college stage. In his junior season at Colorado, Sanders threw for over 3,000 yards, showcasing a quick release and the ability to extend plays with his mobility—traits that could translate well to the pros. His performance in high-stakes games, including upsets against ranked opponents, has elevated his draft stock, with many mock drafts projecting him as a top-10 pick. For the Browns, who hold a first-round selection in 2025 (potentially in the mid-to-late range depending on their season), Sanders represents a potential heir apparent or even a challenger to Watson if the veteran's struggles persist.
The idea of drafting Sanders isn't without its intrigue and controversy. Deion Sanders has publicly expressed a desire for his son to land in a stable, supportive environment, name-dropping teams like the Atlanta Falcons or Las Vegas Raiders as preferable destinations. However, the Browns' defensive prowess, led by stars like Myles Garrett, and their offensive weapons such as Amari Cooper and Nick Chubb (when healthy), could make Cleveland an appealing spot. Yet, the franchise's history of quarterback instability—dating back to the post-1999 expansion era with names like Tim Couch, Baker Mayfield, and now Watson—might give pause. Critics argue that inserting a rookie like Sanders into a high-pressure situation could hinder his development, especially if Watson remains the starter and the team is in win-now mode.
This draft speculation ties directly into the Browns' current quarterback competition, which has heated up during training camp and preseason. Deshaun Watson, fully cleared from his 2023 shoulder surgery, has shown flashes of his old form in practices, emphasizing improved mechanics and chemistry with new wideout Jerry Jeudy. However, questions linger about his ability to stay healthy and perform consistently over a full season. Behind him, Jameis Winston brings experience and a cannon arm, having thrown for over 5,000 yards in his last full starting stint with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2019. Winston's enthusiasm has been evident, as he mentors younger players while vying for reps.
Tyler Huntley, a former Baltimore Ravens backup known for his scrambling ability, adds another layer of intrigue. His familiarity with Stefanski's offensive scheme—rooted in similar principles to those he experienced under Greg Roman in Baltimore—makes him a dark horse in the competition. Then there's Dorian Thompson-Robinson, the 2023 fifth-round pick from UCLA, who started three games as a rookie and displayed raw potential despite some rookie mistakes. Thompson-Robinson has bulked up in the offseason and focused on decision-making, aiming to prove he's more than just a developmental project.
The competition has manifested in preseason games, where each quarterback has had opportunities to shine. Winston's deep-ball accuracy has stood out, while Huntley's mobility has created explosive plays. Thompson-Robinson, in particular, has impressed with his poise under pressure, completing key passes in simulated game situations. Stefanski has been coy about the pecking order, stating in press conferences that "all these guys are pushing each other, and that's what we want—iron sharpening iron." This approach not only builds depth but also prepares the team for the inevitable injuries that plague the position, as evidenced by Pickett's recent setback.
Beyond the on-field battles, the Browns' front office, led by general manager Andrew Berry, must weigh long-term strategy. With Watson's contract—a fully guaranteed $230 million deal—tying up significant cap space through 2026, trading him seems unlikely without a massive dead-cap hit. This financial commitment underscores the need for a reliable backup plan, whether through internal development or the draft. Enter Shedeur Sanders again: his college tape reveals a quarterback who thrives in pro-style offenses, with excellent pocket presence and the ability to read defenses. Scouts praise his football IQ, inherited from his father's Hall of Fame pedigree, and his resilience in the face of Colorado's offensive line struggles.
However, drafting Sanders would require the Browns to potentially maneuver up in the draft order, especially if teams like the New York Giants, Tennessee Titans, or Las Vegas Raiders— all with quarterback uncertainties—target him first. The 2025 class is stacked with talent, including Miami's Cam Ward and Texas' Quinn Ewers, but Sanders' star power and marketability could make him a priority for a franchise like Cleveland seeking to energize its fanbase.
In the broader NFL context, Pickett's injury serves as a reminder of the position's precariousness. The young quarterback, once heralded as the Steelers' future, has faced scrutiny for his size and injury history, including concussions and now ribs. His situation parallels that of other young QBs who've struggled to stay on the field, prompting teams to prioritize depth and versatility. For the Browns, this means not only fostering competition but also scouting aggressively for the next generation.
As the regular season approaches, the Browns' quarterback room remains a focal point. Will Watson reclaim his elite status and silence doubters? Can the backups provide the necessary insurance? And looking ahead, could Shedeur Sanders be the piece that finally stabilizes the position for years to come? These questions loom large over Cleveland, a team with Super Bowl aspirations built on a stout defense but hindered by offensive inconsistency. The coming months will reveal much, but one thing is clear: in the NFL, quarterback stability is never guaranteed, and the Browns are navigating these choppy waters with a mix of veteran savvy, young promise, and draft-day dreams.
This ongoing saga underscores the high-stakes nature of the position, where injuries like Pickett's can shift narratives overnight, and prospects like Sanders represent hope for the future. For Browns fans, weary of the quarterback merry-go-round, the competition and speculation offer both excitement and anxiety—a familiar cocktail in the Dawg Pound. As training camp progresses into the preseason finale, all eyes will be on how these dynamics unfold, potentially setting the stage for a pivotal offseason decision on Sanders or another blue-chip talent. (Word count: 1,248)
Read the Full Sporting News Article at:
[ https://www.sportingnews.com/ca/nfl/cleveland-browns/news/kenny-pickett-injury-shedeur-sanders-browns-qb-competition/eb7f8696a0a249c83576ddf3 ]
Similar Media and Entertainment Publications
[ Last Saturday ]: Sporting News
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Saturday ]: Sporting News
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Saturday ]: Yahoo Sports
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Thursday ]: Sports Illustrated
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Thursday ]: Sports Illustrated
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Thursday ]: SB Nation
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Wednesday ]: Sporting News
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Wednesday ]: Sports Illustrated
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Wednesday ]: Athlon Sports
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Monday ]: Sporting News
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition
[ Last Monday ]: Sporting News
Category: Sports and Competition
Category: Sports and Competition