Media & Entertainment
Mon, August 11, 2025
[ Last Monday ]: Deadline.com
[ Last Monday ]: syracuse.com
[ Last Monday ]: Fox News
[ Last Monday ]: wjla
[ Last Monday ]: Seeking Alpha
[ Last Monday ]: Chicago Tribune
[ Last Monday ]: KUTV
[ Last Monday ]: BBC
[ Last Monday ]: Houston Public Media
Sun, August 10, 2025
[ Last Sunday ]: WMUR
[ Last Sunday ]: The Citizen
[ Last Sunday ]: wjla
[ Last Sunday ]: Channel 3000
[ Last Sunday ]: Patch
[ Last Sunday ]: Futurism
[ Last Sunday ]: BBC
[ Last Sunday ]: PC Gamer
[ Last Sunday ]: sportskeeda.com
[ Last Sunday ]: Chowhound
[ Last Sunday ]: Columbus Dispatch
[ Last Sunday ]: Houston Public Media
Sat, August 9, 2025
[ Last Saturday ]: WFMZ-TV
[ Last Saturday ]: montanarightnow
[ Last Saturday ]: BBC
[ Last Saturday ]: Fox News
[ Last Saturday ]: Parade
[ Last Saturday ]: wjla
[ Last Saturday ]: Mid Day
[ Last Saturday ]: AZ Central
[ Last Saturday ]: Cleveland
[ Last Saturday ]: Arizona Daily Star
[ Last Saturday ]: Daily Gazette, Sterling, Ill.
Fri, August 8, 2025
[ Last Friday ]: Fox News
[ Last Friday ]: The Wrap
[ Last Friday ]: Deadline.com
[ Last Friday ]: reuters.com
[ Last Friday ]: wjla
[ Last Friday ]: The Daily Star
[ Last Friday ]: The News International
[ Last Friday ]: Forbes
Wed, August 6, 2025
[ Last Wednesday ]: lbbonline
[ Last Wednesday ]: The Wrap
[ Last Wednesday ]: Deadline
[ Last Wednesday ]: Variety
[ Last Wednesday ]: The Hollywood Reporter
[ Last Wednesday ]: Fox 5 NY
[ Last Wednesday ]: NJ.com
[ Last Wednesday ]: Heavy.com
[ Last Wednesday ]: TheWrap
[ Last Wednesday ]: profootballnetwork.com
[ Last Wednesday ]: Eurogamer
[ Last Wednesday ]: Houston Public Media
[ Last Wednesday ]: yahoo.com
[ Last Wednesday ]: Salon
[ Last Wednesday ]: Moneywise
[ Last Wednesday ]: KCAU Sioux City
[ Last Wednesday ]: dpa international
[ Last Wednesday ]: The Telegraph
[ Last Wednesday ]: Seeking Alpha
[ Last Wednesday ]: wjla
[ Last Wednesday ]: The Financial Times
Tue, August 5, 2025
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Fox News
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: BBC
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: ThePrint
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Futurism
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Forbes
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Fortune
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: TheWrap
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Today
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: The Straits Times
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: wjla
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: moneycontrol.com
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: The Herald-Dispatch
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: washingtonpost.com
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: The Financial Express
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Omaha.com
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Radio Times
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: yahoo.com
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: West Virginia Watch
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: fox17online
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: HuffPost
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Free Malaysia Today
[ Tue, Aug 05th ]: Houston Public Media
Mon, August 4, 2025
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: L.A. Mag
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Jerusalem Post
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: WDAF
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Democrat and Chronicle
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: ThePrint
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Deadline.com
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Utah News Dispatch
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: KLAS articles
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: WTWO Terre Haute
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: The Observer, La Grande, Ore.
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Associated Press
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: WISH-TV
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: The 4th Official
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: KMID Midland
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Variety
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: fox17online
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Los Angeles Times
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Time
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: IndieWire
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Athlon Sports
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Fox News
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: OPB
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: New York Post
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: The Hollywood Reporter
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Houston Public Media
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Deadline
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: The New Republic
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Mandatory
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: RTE Online
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: AOL
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: The Tribune-Democrat, Johnstown, Pa.
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Forbes
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Football Italia
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Ohio Capital Journal
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: wjla
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Florida Today
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: Madrid Universal
[ Mon, Aug 04th ]: BBC
Sun, August 3, 2025
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: KTSM
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Semafor
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: SheKnows
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Deadline
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: NY Post
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Miami Herald
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: WCIA Champaign
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Fox News
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: The Enquirer
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Athlon Sports
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Get Spanish Football News
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: legit
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: USA TODAY
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: al.com
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: The New York Times
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: news4sanantonio
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: TV Insider
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Sports Illustrated
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Reuters
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: The Telegraph
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: syracuse.com
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: sportskeeda.com
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: KOLR Springfield
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Houston Public Media
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: wjla
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: KREX articles
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Local 12 WKRC Cincinnati
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: KCAU Sioux City
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Telangana Today
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: TheWrap
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: Seeking Alpha
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: fox17online
[ Sun, Aug 03rd ]: KSTP-TV
Sat, August 2, 2025
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Chicago Tribune
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Local 12 WKRC Cincinnati
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: WGME
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Impacts
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Salon
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: wjla
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: legit
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Colorado Public Radio
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Honolulu Star-Advertiser
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Aggies Wire
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Fox 11 News
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Fox News
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: KRON
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Press-Republican, Plattsburgh, N.Y.
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: The Blast
[ Sat, Aug 02nd ]: Variety
Fri, August 1, 2025
[ Fri, Aug 01st ]: Sports Illustrated
[ Fri, Aug 01st ]: Forbes
[ Fri, Aug 01st ]: Houston Public Media
Thu, July 31, 2025
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Parade
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Fox Sports
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Sports Illustrated
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Houston Public Media
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: newsbytesapp.com
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Deadline
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Source New Mexico
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Frontstretch
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Indianapolis Star
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Wrap
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Fortune
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Independent US
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: MLive
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Cool Down
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Philadelphia Inquirer
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: West Virginia Watch
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Burlington Free Press
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Financial Express
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: BBC
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: The Irish News
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: AFP
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Forbes
The Engines of Our Ingenuity 1417: A Metaphor Collapses | Houston Public Media
//media-entertainment.news-articles.net/content/ .. 7-a-metaphor-collapses-houston-public-media.html
Published in Media and Entertainment on Sunday, August 3rd 2025 at 2:41 GMT by Houston Public Media🞛 This publication is a summary or evaluation of another publication 🞛 This publication contains editorial commentary or bias from the source
Episode: 1417 In which the medieval clock metaphor finally collapses. Today, a metaphor dies.
The Collapse of a Metaphor: Rethinking the Tacoma Narrows Bridge Disaster
In the annals of engineering history, few events capture the imagination quite like the spectacular failure of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge on November 7, 1940. This suspension bridge, spanning the Puget Sound in Washington State, was a marvel of modern design when it opened just four months earlier. At the time, it was the third-longest suspension bridge in the world, with a main span stretching 2,800 feet. Its slender, elegant profile represented the cutting edge of bridge engineering, pushing the boundaries of what was possible with lighter materials and more efficient construction techniques. However, this very innovation sowed the seeds of its downfall, leading to one of the most dramatic structural collapses ever recorded on film. The footage of the bridge twisting and undulating wildly before plunging into the waters below has become iconic, symbolizing the perils of hubris in engineering and the unpredictable forces of nature.
From the moment it was completed, the bridge exhibited unusual behavior. Workers and drivers nicknamed it "Galloping Gertie" because of its tendency to oscillate in the wind. Even mild breezes would set the roadway into vertical waves, sometimes rising and falling by several feet. Engineers attempted various fixes, such as adding dampers and tie-down cables, but these proved insufficient. On that fateful morning in 1940, with winds gusting up to 40 miles per hour, the oscillations grew increasingly violent. The center span began to twist in a torsional motion, with one side rising while the other fell, creating a corkscrew effect. Eyewitnesses described the scene as mesmerizing yet terrifying—the bridge seemed alive, writhing like a living creature in distress. Eventually, the stresses became too great: cables snapped, sections of the roadway broke apart, and the entire structure plummeted into the narrows below. Miraculously, no human lives were lost, though a dog perished in an abandoned car on the bridge.
For decades, this catastrophe has been explained through the lens of resonance, a concept familiar from physics classrooms. Resonance occurs when an external force is applied at a frequency that matches the natural frequency of a system, causing amplitudes to build up dramatically. Think of a child on a swing: if you push at just the right moment, the swing goes higher and higher. In popular retellings, the Tacoma Narrows Bridge is often portrayed as a victim of resonance, with the wind acting like rhythmic pushes that amplified the bridge's natural oscillations until it tore itself apart. This explanation has permeated textbooks, documentaries, and even metaphors in broader culture. The bridge's collapse has been invoked as a symbol for the downfall of rigid systems—be it a political regime, a scientific paradigm, or a personal belief structure—that fail when subjected to persistent, resonant pressures. It's a compelling narrative: the idea that small, repeated forces can topple giants if they hit the right frequency.
But here's where the metaphor begins to crumble under closer scrutiny. The true cause of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge's failure wasn't resonance at all, but a more insidious phenomenon known as aeroelastic flutter. To understand the distinction, we must delve into the physics of vibrations and fluid dynamics. Resonance requires an external driving force that is periodic and tuned to the system's natural frequency. In the case of the bridge, if resonance were at play, the wind would need to deliver puffs or vortices at exactly the bridge's oscillatory frequency, steadily pumping energy into the system. However, investigations after the collapse, including wind tunnel tests and mathematical modeling, revealed that the wind wasn't providing such a tuned input. Instead, the bridge was experiencing self-excited oscillations, where the structure itself interacted with the airflow in a way that extracted energy from the wind, feeding back into its own motion.
Aeroelastic flutter is a dynamic instability that arises in flexible structures exposed to fluid flows, like air or water. It occurs when the elastic deformations of the structure alter the aerodynamic forces acting upon it, creating a positive feedback loop. For the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, the key issue was its unusually flexible design. The roadway was a thin, plate-girder structure rather than a deeper truss, which made it lighter and cheaper but also more prone to bending and twisting. As wind flowed over the bridge, it created alternating vortices on either side—a phenomenon called vortex shedding. Normally, these vortices would dissipate harmlessly, but the bridge's flexibility allowed it to move in response, which in turn modified the airflow. This motion changed the angle of attack of the wind on the deck, generating lift and drag forces that amplified the twisting. Once initiated, the flutter grew exponentially because the energy came from the steady wind stream itself, not from any resonant forcing. It's akin to a flag flapping in the breeze: the flag doesn't need periodic gusts; the steady wind provides the energy, and the flag's motion sustains the instability.
This misunderstanding has persisted for so long partly because resonance is an easier concept to grasp and teach. It's intuitive and has clear analogies in everyday life, like shattering a glass with a singer's high note or soldiers breaking step on a bridge to avoid resonant collapse (a myth itself, but one that reinforces the idea). Flutter, on the other hand, requires a grasp of coupled aeroelastic systems, involving equations from structural dynamics, aerodynamics, and control theory. Post-collapse analyses by engineers like Theodore von Kármán and others confirmed flutter as the culprit. They noted that the bridge's torsional mode of vibration had a natural frequency that, when excited by the wind-induced forces, led to divergence rather than simple amplification.
The implications of this correction extend beyond engineering. The Tacoma Narrows disaster prompted a revolution in bridge design. Subsequent suspension bridges, such as the rebuilt Tacoma Narrows Bridge in 1950 and others like the Golden Gate, incorporated deeper trusses, slotted decks to reduce wind resistance, and tuned mass dampers to mitigate oscillations. Wind tunnel testing became mandatory for major structures, and aeroelastic considerations are now integral to aerospace engineering as well—think of airplane wings, which must be designed to avoid flutter at high speeds.
Yet, the resonance metaphor lingers in cultural discourse, often misapplied. It's been used to describe everything from the fall of the Soviet Union (persistent ideological pressures resonating with internal weaknesses) to market crashes (economic forces building up at a systemic frequency). But if the actual physics was flutter—a self-sustaining instability triggered by inherent design flaws—then the metaphor collapses. It suggests that failures aren't always about external rhythms overwhelming a system but about internal vulnerabilities that, once engaged, draw energy from the environment to self-destruct. This shifts the narrative from inevitability to preventability: with better understanding and design, such collapses can be averted.
Consider how this applies to other fields. In medicine, a disease might not spread through resonant waves of infection but through feedback loops where the body's responses exacerbate the condition. In climate science, tipping points like ice sheet melting aren't necessarily resonant but involve self-amplifying cycles where warming begets more warming. Even in psychology, concepts like spiraling anxiety might better align with flutter than resonance—internal dynamics feeding on steady stressors rather than timed triggers.
The Tacoma Narrows Bridge, then, serves as a cautionary tale not just of engineering overreach but of the dangers of oversimplified explanations. By clinging to the resonance myth, we risk missing the nuanced realities of complex systems. The bridge's "galloping" wasn't a dance to an external tune but a fatal flutter in the wind, a reminder that metaphors, like bridges, must be built on solid foundations. As we continue to engineer ever-grander structures—from skyscrapers defying gravity to spacecraft piercing the atmosphere—let us honor the lessons of 1940 by embracing the full complexity of the forces at play. Only then can we ensure that our ingenuity doesn't lead to unintended collapse.
(Word count: 1,128)
Read the Full Houston Public Media Article at:
[ https://www.houstonpublicmedia.org/articles/shows/engines-of-our-ingenuity/engines-podcast/2025/08/03/527318/the-engines-of-our-ingenuity-1417-a-metaphor-collapses/ ]
Similar Media and Entertainment Publications
[ Thu, Jul 31st ]: Houston Public Media
[ Tue, Jul 29th ]: Houston Public Media
[ Mon, Jul 21st ]: Houston Public Media